The Market Pricing of Other-Than-Temporary Impairments

ABSTRACT

When the fair value of an investment security falls below amortized cost and there is significant doubt that the firm can hold the security until the fair value recovers, an other-than-temporary impairment (OTTI) is recognized in net income. Thus, an OTTI is a disclosure about the prospect of recovering an unrealized loss. Our findings suggest that investors priced banks' OTTI recognition during and after the financial crisis. Investors were unable to fully anticipate reported OTTIs, and priced OTTIs incrementally to reported unrealized gains/losses. After banks were required to bifurcate OTTIs, investors priced only the portion of OTTI recognized in earnings. Our results suggest that reporting unrealized losses in earnings via an OTTI changes how investors price the losses. The results inform recent standard-setting initiatives to expand disclosure about changes in fair value.

Keywords:  fair value accounting, mark-to-market accounting, other-than-temporary impairments, unrealized losses, other comprehensive income, financial crisis, commercial banks

Source : Brad A. Badertscher, Jeffrey J. Burks, and Peter D. Easton (2014) The Market Pricing of Other-Than-Temporary Impairments. The Accounting Review: May 2014, Vol. 89, No. 3, pp. 811-838.